Friday, September 3, 2010

Confronting whiteness

I haven't felt the need to write here in a while, but now that the semester is underway that desire has surfaced. It helps to write through difficult emotions and challenges that I can't seem to sort out mentally. And the gears have been turning and turning more so than usual and in a different way. The majority of the youth I've worked with have been youth of color / language minority youth from low-income neighborhoods. Now that I am a TA, I will be working with a youth population that is largely unfamiliar to me as an educator: college students. More specifically, white, middle-class, uncritical college students.

The first assignment we had them do was a reaction paper in which they discussed how their schooling prepared them to get to UT. We encouraged them to mention factors such as race, gender, citizenship, language, etc. in their analysis and very few even decided to engage in that conversation. As a person of color it is still uncomfortable for me to discuss matters of race with non-POC, but it is something I can easily do with other POC. What is now becoming crystal clear to me is that non-POC for the most part don't even discuss matters of race with each other because they don't see themselves and white spaces in racialized terms - it is just the norm and thus there is no need to address it or problematize it.

Which leads me back to the gears that are working overtime and grinding away internally. I am struggling with how to challenge white privilege with students who do not know how to articulate it. Youth of color, even those who are really young, grow up with a racialized awareness of our world that white youth largely do not have to think about because they are not forced to think about it. Therefore even though they're young, YOC are not afraid or as hesitant to participate in those conversations.

The last thing I want is for my students to feel as though I am attacking them and to end up with feelings of guilt that are unproductive and limiting. I want to create the kind of space that encourages discomfort as we grapple with these topics and as we force ourselves and each other to think about our experiences in a racialized way. But that's easier said than done, no?

Overall I am also starting to feel a lot of pressure because I know that I am probably the first "educated Chicana" that some of these students have seen/met. Although they haven't said it, their reaction papers essentially shouted that they've lived in very insulated and white communities. There is a lot of truth in the sentiments that other POC have expressed - it is burdensome to feel as though you have to perform perfectly so that you are not seen as a "detriment to your race." In this scenario I want my interactions with them to be positive so that they might begin to challenge any stereotypes they grew up with and messages they internalized over the years.

Perhaps I am being overly optimistic and unrealistic about what I can do over the course of this semester. Even so, it does not mean I am not going to try and challenge myself and my students to engage in these difficult conversations. I also know that my presence means a lot symbolically to the students of color in my discussion section who were also undoubtedly surprised that their TA is a Chicana. I think it will make me happy if I can disrupt even one student's assumptions about the nature of privilege and the inequalities that abound.

No comments: